In the later years of his career, John Lennon stopped wearing rose-tinted glasses when it came to the Beatles’ songs — in particular, his own.
He continued to hold a warm spot for some of the group’s’ earliest tunes, like “All My Loving,” and for a number of those from their later era, including “Strawberry Fields Forever,” “In My Life” and “Hey Jude.”
But he viewed many others with a critic’s unsparing eye. His most withering condemnations were saved for songs that were stamped out in cookie-cutter form or peeled off as nonsensical filler. “It’s Only Love” is an example of the former, a Help! track he called “abysmal”, while the latter includes Abbey Road’s “Mean Mr. Mustard,” a bit of light-hearted fluff he denounced as “a piece of garbage.”
And then there’s the song Lennon called his “least favorite.” It appeared on the group’s 1965 album Rubber Soul, which may seem odd, given that record’s status as the group’s first conceptual work, in which every song received its own well-considered musical arrangement.
Released on December 3 of that year, it was the Beatles’ sixth album and the second to come out in 1965, following Help! As long-players go, it was something of a rush job, with 13 of its 14 songs written and recorded in two month’s time following the Fab Four’s U.S. tour. (Another two original songs — “We Can Work It Out” and “Day Tripper” — were also created for a single release during this time, such was the Beatles’ remarkable creative output.)
Even so, the band took care in the studio to give the songs exactly what they required, experimenting with folkier sounds and new instruments, including George Harrison’s sitar on “Norwegian Wood (This Bird Has Flown)” and Paul McCartney’s fuzz bass on Harrison’s “Think for Yourself.”
As for that 14th song? It was “Wait,” a leftover from the Help! sessions. It was revived and added to Rubber Soul’s lineup when no one could muster the strength to write and record one more song to meet the long-player’s requisite 14-track quota.